Normally, I eat upstairs at Whiskey Creek for simpler fare, fish tacos or a burger, but I felt like a steak and salad. So downstairs it was for The Whiskey Wedge and the Friday night Prime Rib. The metaphor for my dining experience is appropriate for the season in which I'm dining, a 16 year old youth snowboarding with buddies on the slopes of Mammoth for the first time. Fast, somewhat haphazard, and the youthful urge to get down the hill without much style or grace but proclaim to all that he just carved up another killer run.
The Wedge was uninspired, as though they didn’t try. Sure the lettuce was cold and generous, but the bleu cheese dressing was loose and underseasoned. The candied walnuts, an afterthought simply put on the side of the salad. There was also some other reddish dressing put over the top of the bleu cheese dressing, to what end I don’t know. Nothing special really, although it came out very quickly from the kitchen.
As for the prime rib, it looked perfect and medium rare, but was missing a roasted crust around the outside. Secondly, a brown sauce was poured all over the meat, for what reason I have no idea. The prime rib was cooked properly, so why add some canned or bottled sauce to it? The sauce was horrible and tasted like Campbell’s reduced beef broth combined with pureed mushroom soup, desecrating the prime rib. I took the mashed potatoes and created a dam around my prime rib mitigating some of the damage wrought by the foul sauce.
Another worry I have, the wine list is dated, which may indicate problems with buying habits of both consumers and the staff. There seems to be plenty of wine and plenty of choices, almost too many when it comes to the offerings by the glass, all indicative of confusion rather than vision for what Whiskey Creek should be, a premier dining property in town with clear direction other than speed and tons of offerings. When I see 02, 03, 04 Cabs on the list, that have had recent releases, it begins to worry me. I'm all for having verticals of wine but it's un-necessary at a place like this. They should have recent vintages of the most popular wines in the LA and San Diego area.
As I opened with my reckless snowboarder metaphor, one thing about downstairs at Whiskey Creek that I couldn’t complain too much about…they’re fast; but if I had to do it over again, I’d eat upstairs in the bar. I think this place could be a real gem in Mammoth if they only took a step back, re-evaluated what they were doing, slow down, and think about what they want to do as a professional snowboarder, just go fast and board or step up their game and board the half-pipe with style.
Recent Comments